# Ben Heath: creative and copy playbook

This file covers Ben Heath's creative and copy method, sourced from his own videos. The
bracketed tags are YouTube video IDs with an upload date; `sources.md` maps them to URLs.
The ad copy templates in section 9 are written in his style for us to use. They are not
his scripts.

---

## 1. Creative's place in the system

- Offer comes first and creative second: "we are in a creative platform" [crId74rHjuA 2025-10].
- In his 5-step diagnostic, creative is the most common problem [vaBxYgZ7MAU 2026-05].
- Small budgets fail mostly because of creative, not targeting [XLagiyzYYpE 2026-02].
- "I'd rather you took more money out of your ad budget and put it into producing great
  creative." [crId74rHjuA]
- Creative needs to look native to the platform. Don't run repurposed TV or billboard ads,
  don't use hashtags, and always include a clear CTA [XtoJVbu4Bys 2026-07].

---

## 2. Start from the customer, not the product [inJWYXen3Xc 2026-02]

1. **Define the ideal customer.**
   - If you already have customers, find the most profitable 10–20% and design ads for
     them alone.
   - If you're new, look at competitors and make an educated guess.
2. **List that customer's buying reasons.** Examples: price, convenience, going above and
   beyond, track record, portfolio, exclusivity, status. Use benefit ladders to get from
   features to benefits.
3. **Use one angle per ad.** "Have one of those reasons… what we'd refer to as an ad angle
   per ad."
   - "I see far more ads that are too complicated… than… too simple."
   - When several angles are bundled into one ad, the real winner gets buried "in fourth
     place."
4. **Each audience slice gets its own winning angle.**
   - For his own agency, "results" wins with owner-operators.
   - For Fortune 500 marketing managers, "anxiety alleviation / a defensible decision"
     wins. That audience needs credibility proof: spend figures, partner badges, press, and
     video of him on stage.
5. **Match the message to the market segment you want.**
   - For high-net-worth customers, don't lead with price. Lead with time saved,
     convenience and status [XLagiyzYYpE 2026-02].
   - Static ads especially need persona-specific messaging, for example "running shorts for
     sub-zero temperatures, long distance, don't chafe." Splitting a market into 10 slices
     with one ad each is "absolutely fine" [2VWnj9C9PvQ 2026-10].

**Sources of creative diversity after Andromeda** [a6-l6BD3dDg 2025-11]:
- Awareness stage: unaware, problem-aware, solution-aware.
- Different pain points.
- Different desires. Airport fast-track example: time saving, anxiety relief, feeling swish.
- Different avatars. Gym example: weight loss, muscle gain, sport, rehab, older members.
- Different formats and styles.
- Background or colour tweaks do **not** count as diversity.

---

## 3. Formats: video vs static vs carousel

| Date | Source | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 2025-02 | YouTube poll, ~3,000 votes [GPp8Y-lKzJw] | Video 60%, image 27%, carousel 9%, other 4% |
| 2025-02 | His 400+ managed accounts | ~58% video |
| 2025-06 | Business manager, 1,000+ accounts [oMhsPXBTqtg] | Video wins "about 60% of the time", up from ~45% two years earlier |
| 2026-10 (newest) | Poll [2VWnj9C9PvQ] | "Static, 54%, video, 38%, 8% other." Internal data agrees: Meta is shifting budget to statics inside mixed ad sets |

He gives two reasons statics are winning: attention spans are shrinking ("you're actually
only telling 10% of people about your offer" with video), and statics now stand out in
video-heavy feeds.

**Rules**
- **Run several formats in every ad set**, all the time.
  - Different people respond to different formats.
  - Meta sequences them, using video for awareness and statics as the follow-up.
  - "Don't just make statics." Example mix for 20 ads: "16 statics and four videos."
- **"The complexity of the ad format should match the size of the ask."** [GPp8Y-lKzJw]
  - Cheap impulse buys and lead magnets: images and carousels.
  - Big asks such as high-ticket services: longer video with proof and testimonials.
- **Where video still wins:** new inventions or concepts that need explaining, and
  expertise-based selling to cold audiences.
- **Warm audiences** do well with statics: show the offer, a familiar face, and the quick
  next step.
- "If you're going to do video ads, they need to be good." A poor video won't beat a strong
  image.
- **AI-looking statics "do not perform well at all."** Using AI to place a real product
  photo into a scene or onto a model is fine.
- His prediction: animated statics, where text or elements fly in, are the next trend.
- Prepare assets for 3 placement shapes: feed (1:1 or 4:5), vertical (9:16), and landscape.
  Adjust caption position for reels and stories [846INGFormA 2024-11; KgO_J6pwv9I 2023-09].

---

## 4. Styles to cover [8dJxOaZrK1M 2026-03; 6TRy9eUAPVg 2026-08; XtoJVbu4Bys 2026-07]

**Styles**
- UGC
- Influencer or creator partnership. Keep this separate from UGC: "UGC from a person with
  no following is different from creator partnership ads."
- Founder-led
- Product demonstration. Good for businesses with a portfolio to show.
- Customer testimonial, single or compilation.
- Hybrids, such as a founder video that ends in testimonials.
- Animation, slideshow, meme, ASMR, myth-busting or FAQ, podcast-style integrations.
- Review statics, and lo-fi statics made in a TikTok-style editor.

**Rules**
- **Diversity is not one style.** "All UGC" or "all similar statics" doesn't count as
  diversification [6TRy9eUAPVg].
- **The best brands run 78–300+ active ads** across many styles and placements. His examples
  are HelloFresh and Huel [XtoJVbu4Bys].

---

## 5. Hooks: the highest-leverage creative element

**Why hooks matter**
- The hook is the opening scene and opening line, roughly the first 3 seconds.
- "90% or more of people will not make it past those first 3 seconds." [oMhsPXBTqtg 2025-06]
- That means two ads that share the last 57 seconds but have different first 3 seconds
  are "a completely different ad" to most viewers.
- Ad fatigue is mostly hook fatigue: "We should probably rename it as hook fatigue."

**Hook rate**
- Hook rate = 3-second video plays ÷ impressions.
- Above 10% is good. Below 5% is poor [mycqb92wJqk 2024-09].
- Example: changing only the hook took hook rate from 8% to 33% [8dJxOaZrK1M].

**The hook multiplication recipe** [oMhsPXBTqtg 2025-06]
1. Script and record **2 full video ads**, modelled on competitor ads that are working.
2. Pick **10 visual hooks**. Options:
   - Different locations or backgrounds.
   - Different camera angles of the same room.
   - Outdoors.
   - Props such as a whiteboard, laptop or phone.
   - Outfit changes.
   - Face-to-camera or not.
   - A client-result screenshot as the opening frame.
3. Write **10 verbal hooks** and deliver all of them in every location.
4. That gives "200 ad combos, even though you've only got two full ads" (2 × 10 × 10).
5. Find the winning hooks and feed them into the next batch.
6. When a winner fatigues, keep its verbal hook and body and swap only the visual hook. This
   can stretch a 6-week ad to 6+ months.
7. Optional extra: test different CTA endings, but only on rewatchable, entertaining winners.

He states the same idea more simply elsewhere: "two video ads, five hooks each, different
scenes" [6TRy9eUAPVg 2026-08], and "two full ads with the 10 different hooks, you have 20
different ads" [crId74rHjuA 2025-10].

**Verbal hook types** [oMhsPXBTqtg]

| Type | Template | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Yes-question | "Do you struggle to …?" | "Do you struggle to get your Facebook ads to work?" |
| Conditional / call-out | "If you [qualifier], [promise]." | "If you spend more than $100,000 per month on Facebook ads, we guarantee you a 30% improvement in your ROAS in 3 months." / "If you can't walk your dog in the park because of reactivity…" |
| Outstanding result | "See how [client] [specific result]." | "See how this client added $100,000 of value to their home with our solar panels." These also work as headlines. |

**Hook testing after Andromeda**
- Meta may treat ads that differ only in the hook as the same ad and enter just one of them
  into the auction [onFwSud9C2Y 2026-02].
- Test hook variants with the **Creative Testing tool**. Put the winning hook into the main
  ad set next to genuinely different ads.
- "Please do not throw out the hook method."

---

## 6. Proof in every ad [z3LiJ0PbY-0 2024-10]

- "Every single ad that I have live has proof in it."
- **Proof types:**
  - Video testimonials (best). Written testimonials also work.
  - Result screenshots, or screen recordings, which are more believable in skeptical
    industries.
  - Photos of completed work.
  - Transformations. Avoid split before/after body images, which get disapproved.
    Sequential before/after for things like kitchens is fine.
  - Trustpilot ratings, accreditations, big-name clients.
- **Case study:** for a physiotherapy chain, a ~90-second compilation of real client
  reactions (about 5 seconds per clip, close to 50 clips gathered) "more than doubled" ROAS.
  The offer and budget stayed the same.
  - It worked because it doesn't look like an ad and isn't a pitch.
  - Average watch time was low, and "who cares about average watch time if your return on ad
    spend is much better."
- **When the creative is pure proof,** the copy and headline must carry the offer.
- **Proof raises "perceived likelihood of achievement"** in the value equation. Established
  businesses have a proof moat, so invest in capturing proof.

---

## 7. Creators and partnership ads ("as close to a Meta ad cheat code as you can get")

Sources: [crId74rHjuA 2025-10; gbcQq19jbjs 2026-06; 8dJxOaZrK1M 2026-03; 3ReT1bzLFhU 2026-10;
6TRy9eUAPVg 2026-08]

**Why they work**
- They are the best-performing ads across his client accounts.
- Meta's figures: "on average a 13% higher click-through rate and a 71% higher brand lift."
- He has seen ROAS go from "2x to a 4x or a 6x", or "3x into an 8x", with the right creator.

**Finding creators**
- Use Meta **Creator Marketplace** (All tools → Engage audience). You need a professional
  Instagram account or one connected to a Page.
- Look first at creators already active on partnership ads.
- Check engagement against follower count. Around 3% of accounts engaged is a red flag.
- A creator with 5,000 followers can work if they are your exact market.
- Start with micro-influencers.

**Budget and spreading risk**
- Some creators will make an ad for about $100. A larger example: 2 reels for $1,000, plus
  up to about $500 for ad rights.
- Start with **2–4 creators** to spread risk.
- Expect to contact around 20 creators to get 2 replies.

**Rights**
- Always tick **"add boost permission"**, which gives you ad rights.
- Organic posts last about 24 hours. Ads can run for months or years.

**The brief**
- Must-have CTA.
- Two key benefits.
- One credibility point.
- "Two to three video ads with multiple hooks" (or "five hooks each, different scenes").
- Don't script it. Leave style to the creator.

**Running and vetting**
- Run the content as **partnership ads**, which show both identities.
- Check the creator for controversies, and for anything they've said before about your
  category.

---

## 8. Getting creative volume cheaply

- **Model proven ads.** In the Meta Ad Library, competitor ads that have run for 6+ months
  are almost certainly profitable [XLagiyzYYpE 2026-02].
- **Reuse organic content.** Take the Instagram reels or statics that did best organically,
  add a 5–10 second CTA, and run them as ads. Organic content works as free creative testing.
- **Use the hook method** in section 5.
- **Statics** are cheaper and easier for hitting diversity targets [2VWnj9C9PvQ].
- **Mine reviews for angles.** Competitor 5-star reviews show what people love. 1-star
  reviews show pain points you can counter, for example "we guarantee delivery times." Keep a
  swipe folder of ads that caught your attention [fV6P9MF7FqU 2025-04].
- **Be realistic about how much to make.** "I'd much rather you focused on creating four
  really good creatives as opposed to 20 mediocre ones" [fV6P9MF7FqU 2025-04].
  - Treat creative production like a diet: pick a schedule you can stick to. Launching with
    4 very different creatives is fine [onFwSud9C2Y 2026-02].
  - At large scale, run a "creative factory." His example cadence for a $100k/month account
    is "12 new ad creative a week… three content types" [du6rDgRf06g 2026-08]. The caption
    says "three of each", which doesn't add up to 12. Hormozi's teams make 50+ a week
    [oTWfDI_91Fs 2026-09].
- AI tools are mentioned, mostly as sponsor reads (Hollow, Higgsfield, InVideo). Meta's own
  generative tools (Ads Creative Studio, image generation) are mentioned as options. Watch
  for an AI look.

---

## 9. Ad copy

### Order of writing [KgO_J6pwv9I 2023-09]
1. **Headline (= the offer).** This is "the most important part of the ad."
2. Primary text.
3. Creative.

People see these in the reverse order: creative, then headline, then primary text.

### Headline rules
- Be clear, not clever. Curiosity headlines belong in email subject lines.
- State the offer plus one or two benefits, or a price.
- Always name the product or service.
- Examples from his video:
  - "Mouth-wateringly good low calorie cakes"
  - "Reliable fun dog walking just £15"
  - "Book in a free interior design consultation"
  - "Classic Tan Oxford brogues just £45"
- A failed ad often has a headline that doesn't make the offer clear, or a weak offer such
  as a "2% discount."

### Primary text: five techniques
1. **Call-out.** Name the audience, especially one you can't target directly: "Moving home
   or redecorating?" A location call-out ("New Yorkers") screens out tourists.
2. **Benefit-rich.** Turn features into benefits.
3. **Tone matched to the product.** Playful with emojis for cakes, measured for B2B.
4. **CTA at the end.** "Click shop now to brighten up your day."
5. **Length matches the size of the ask.** "Don't make it any longer than it needs to be."
   Shorter is usually better for small asks. Bigger asks justify more copy and proof.

### Variations
- Add up to 5 primary texts, 5 headlines and 5 descriptions per ad, rather than making
  separate ads [13s-G9Uj51A 2026-02].
- "Optimize text per person" (standard enhancements) is fine for most advertisers, but not
  in regulated industries.

### Other copy fields
- **Description:** echo the CTA.
- **CTA button:** pick the button that describes the action: Shop Now, Learn More, Sign Up,
  Book Now.

### Copy templates (our templates, in his style)

**Template A: short, small ask (e-commerce product or lead magnet)**
```
[Call-out question for the ideal customer]?
[Product] that [main benefit] – [proof point: rating / number of customers / result].
[Offer + urgency or guarantee].
Tap [CTA button] to [desired outcome].
Headline: [Product] – [benefit] – [price or offer]
```

**Template B: proof-led, bigger ask (service or high-ticket)**
```
If you [qualifier that defines the ideal customer], this is for you.
[Specific result for a similar client] in [timeframe].
Here's what we do: [3 short benefit lines, one per line].
[Guarantee / risk reversal]. [Scarcity: limited slots this month].
Click [Book Now] to [next step, e.g. book a free call].
Headline: [Outcome] in [timeframe] – [guarantee]
```

**Template C: one angle per ad.** Write one version of Template A or B for each buying
reason (price, convenience, status, speed, proof). Don't combine reasons in one ad.

---

## 10. Testing creative (summary; full rules in framework.md section 7)

**Order of tests**
1. Offer
2. Angle (test around 5, keep the top 2)
3. Format and style, using a batch of ads per style
4. Hooks
5. Small details: headline, primary text, CTA, background. He says "Often we won't get to
   that."

**Tools by situation**

| Situation | Tool |
|---|---|
| Big differences (image vs video, UGC vs founder) | Add as new ads to the main ad set. Andromeda treats them as different ads. |
| Fine detail (hook, overlay, colour vs black-and-white, price banner) | Creative Testing tool: 2–7 ads, judged on CPA or ROAS, default 7 days |
| One new ad in a low-volume account | Push delivery, default 20% of budget for 7 days |

**Ground rules**
- Judge on the north-star metric with enough conversions.
- Never turn off the current winner to force a test.
- Keep "winners waiting in the wings" for when the current winner fatigues.
- Never stop testing: everything fatigues, the platform changes, and competitors copy you.

---

## 11. Creative checklist (from his ad reviews) [XtoJVbu4Bys 2026-07; KgO_J6pwv9I 2023-09; z3LiJ0PbY-0 2024-10]

- [ ] Native to Meta: not a TV ad, billboard or corporate brochure.
- [ ] A hook that stops the scroll in the first 3 seconds, made separately for each video.
- [ ] One clear angle per ad.
- [ ] A clear offer in the headline.
- [ ] Proof included.
- [ ] A clear CTA that tells people what to do next.
- [ ] No hashtags.
- [ ] Landing page matches the ad: same product, offer, colours and imagery. Product-specific
      pages, not a generic homepage.
- [ ] Format complexity matches the size of the ask.
- [ ] A mix of formats and styles in the ad set.
- [ ] Check creative enhancements after every edit, and turn off any that are off-brand.
- [ ] Offers and messages tailored to each avatar where you can (HelloFresh vs Huel lesson).
